Skip to content Skip to navigation

West meets East: Schopenhauer and India

There is a recent revival of interest in Schopenhauer studies in India with the impetus generated from the sincere and meticulous efforts made by IDSS in collaboration with Schopenhauer Research Center at the U of Mainz and the example is the publication of the first book on Schopenhauer and India from India in 2008. However, it is equally true that the Indian scholars have not yet put that much efforts as they perhaps should have to find a connection between Schopenhauer’s philosophy and Indian philosophy especially due to the fact that Schopenhauer had paid such great respect and homage to the Upanishads.


The lacking of serious efforts and interests in India to explore this area chiefly inspired us to organize different academic activities and the result of these exercises have amounted into the publication of this 2nd book in that direction which would be a tribute to that great personality who had adored India so much! We hope that this book will provide a common platform for interaction among the scholars from East and West to express their views on a very important subject on the link between Eastern and Western Philosophy.


We hope that, like the first book, this volume also would significantly contribute to a better understanding not only of the connection between Schopenhauer and Indian philosophical systems but also of the increasing interest and research in this area in India and Germany. It is further expected that this publication will make it possible for the English-speaking scholars particularly in India, to have the opportunity to be associated with the latest research works going on Schopenhauer’s philosophy all over the world.


The book includes papers of eminent scholars providing new lights on the relationship between Schopenhauer’s philosophy and the different Indian philosophical systems such as Vedanta and Buddhism and others. Apart from this there are also papers dealing with Schopenhauer’s views on Sanskrit literature, Schopenhauer and Indian Thought, Schopenhauer in relation to Hegel and Nietzsche, Schopenhauer on Salvation, Death and Contemplation, different levels of Maya in Vedanta and Schopenhauer, Svatantryavada of Kashmir and Voluntarism of Schopenhauer, Schopenhauer’s India Notes, Schopenhauer’s reception in India and Nirvana in Germany and so on. In the publication of this Volume it is hoped that it will accelerate renewal of cross-cultural interaction amongst the scholars of East and West which will further help in mutual understanding.


Schopenhauer’s main works in German language are now almost all available in English translation but still these are not easily available in India. The publication of these new volumes on Schopenhauer and India therefore is expected to provide a rich source of research materials for the English-speaking scholars all over the world including India.




From the Preface of the book:



Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860) the great German Philosopher is one of the first Western thinkers who understood the Upanishads in the true sense of the term.


He was also the first Western thinker who incorporated thoughts of Upanishads in his own philosophy. His appreciation for the Indian philosophy and culture is quite well known. Schopenhauer’s most important work The World as Will and Representation was influenced by the Chandogya Upanishad.



Schopenhauer said –


"In the whole world there is no study so beneficial and so elevating as that of the Upanishads. It has been the solace of my life, it will be the solace of my death”. .


Schopenhauer’s adoration for the Upanishads is clear from the fact that he kept the ‘Oupnekhat’ (Upanishads) open upon his table, and before going to bed at night he used to read few pages from it everyday. He called opening up of Sanskrit literature ‘the greatest gift of our century’ and predicted that the ‘philosophy and knowledge of the Upanishads would become the cherished faith of the West’.


Presently serious research work is going on in different disciplines in different academic Institutions and Universities in the West to examine the influence of Indian Philosophy and culture in the philosophical thinking of Germany, particularly in relation to Arthur Schopenhauer and vice versa. There is a recent revival of interest in Schopenhauer studies in India although it is equally true that the Indian scholars have not done as much work as they should have done to find out the connection between Schopenhauer’s philosophy and Indian philosophy especially due to the fact that Schopenhauer paid such great respect and homage to the Upanishads and Indian Philosophy.


The lacking of serious efforts and interests in India to explore this area chiefly inspired us to compile the first book “Schopenhauer and Indian philosophy: a dialogue between India and Germany” so as to initiate a serious work in this direction which was so far neglected by Indian scholars. This is the 2nd book in that direction and it is a tribute to that great personality who adored India so much! We hope that this book will provide a common platform for interaction to the scholars from East and West to express their views on a very important subject on the link between Eastern and Western Philosophy.


Initially the idea of the present volume sprang up from a discussion in a Roundtable conference organized by IDSS (Indian Division of the Schopenhauer Society) with the support of CSC (Center for Studies in Civilizations) , IPC (Indian Philosophical Congress) and Schopenhauer Gesellschaft, Germany, during the Interim World Philosophy Congress held at the University of Delhi. Later on we invited papers from eminent scholars from India and abroad to compile those into a book form. Hence the papers included here are the combination of the roundtable discussion as well as from an earlier international conference organized by IDSS at Delhi in collaboration with Schopenhauer Research Center, University of Mainz and Schopenhauer Gesellschaft, Germany. Besides these, most of the papers are invited papers from distinguished scholars from India and abroad as mentioned above.


We hope that, like the first book, this volume also would significantly contribute to a better understanding not only of the connection between Schopenhauer and Indian philosophical systems but also of the increasing interest and research in this area in India and Germany. It is further expected that this publication will make it possible for the English-speaking scholars particularly in India, to have the opportunity to be associated with the latest research works going on Schopenhauer all over the world.


I would like to take this opportunity to thank the IPC, Indian Council of Philosophical Research, Deshbandhu College, University of Delhi, India, and Schopenhauer Research Center at the University of Mainz, Schopenhauer Gesellschaft, Germany for sponsoring the Round table in Delhi. Further I would like to thank the distinguished scholars who have contributed their scholarly papers to the book.


Arati Barua
Author


Add new comment

Other Contents by Author

A fresh orgy of violence erupted in Kokrajhar on Tuesday where the Rajdhani Express was attacked by some persons even as the entire train services to and from the Northeast was hit. Unidentified persons pelted stones and attacked the coaches of the Guwahati-bound Rajdhani Express at Gossaigaon in Kokrajhar district damaging four coaches, though there was no casualty or injuries. The train has been turned back and halted at Kamakhyaguri station bordering West Bengal, but the authorities were considering to take it to Coochbehar.
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Tuesday called up Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi and took stock of the situation prevailing in Kokrajhar and Chirang. During the telephonic conversation, the prime minister directed Gogoi to do everything possible to control the violence. The prime minister also promised Gogoi more central assistance. Sporadic incidents of violence and arson are continuing in Kokrajhar, Chirang and Dhubri districts. The situation was tense in Bongaigaon and Udalguri districts. Around 70 houses in four villages at Bijni in Chirang district were torched. Over 50,000 people are housed in relief camps.
Around 400- minority groups staged demonstration in front of the Assam Bhavan in New Delhi on Tuesday. Shouting slogans against Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi, the protesters demanded the scrapping of the BTAD. The Home ministry has asked for the additional deployment of 24 troops to Kokrajhar district. The ministry has commissioned 24 more companies to be deployed in the towns of Dhubri and Chirang. According to Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi, Dispur was monitoring the situation, and confirmed that nearly 50,000 people had fled their homes in the restive Kokrajhar district.
BJP on Tuesday came down heavily on the government for the escalating violence in Kokrajhar, Chirang and Dhubri district where 25 people were killed and 500 families have been displaced. Addressing a press conference in New Delhi on Tuesday, party spokesman Nirmala Sitharaman said that the violence is communal and that the prime minister should immediately issue a statement. She further called it is a problem of illegal migrants. According to her, “Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi was trying hard not to call the violence communal but we know it is so as informed by our team vising the state,”. Meanwhile, a special home ministry team will be rushed to Assam to assess the security...
The Assam police are likely to get Amarjyoti Kalita on the transit remand on Tuesday a day after the prime accused in the G S Road case was arrested in Varansi. The police team from Guwahati has arrived in Varansi to procure him in their remand.Amarjyoti would be produced before a local court on Monday. He would be brought back to Guwahati on Tuesday or Wednesday.
In a major breakthrough, the prime accused in the gory GS Road incident Amarjyoti Kalita surrendered before Varanashi police on Monday. Kalita, a casual employee with Amtron, was on the run after police identified him along with 15 others. He is identified the main culprit of the entire episode where a teenaged girl was molested and stripped by miscreants for 30 minutes in the absence of police. A special investigation team set up to probe the case held 15 miscreants including a journalist and the operation to nab the prime accused. A team of police is on the way to Varanashi to get him in transit remand on Tuesday.
Two persons were killed and 10 others have been injured when a Tata mobile carrying them met with a tragic mishap near Jorhat on Monday. The mishap took place at Badulipar in Teok when the vehicle carrying a group of devotees rammed into a roadside tree on the NH 37 on the way to Sivasagar. Two devotees died on the spot while the injured have rushed to the hospital.
Tarun Gogoi has directed the district authorities in Kokrajhar and Chirang to take stern action to check the violence which has left 14 dead. Talking to reporters on Sunday, he condemned the violence in the district and directed the authorities to take strong measures to stop the violence. He said that he has also directed the police, army and paramilitary to take all possible measures to prevent further outbreak of violence.
Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi on Sunday congratulated Pranab Mukherjee on his victory in the Presidential poll. Talking to reporters he exuded hope that he would provide guidance to the government and the country. Gogoi said,”On behalf of the people of Assam, I congratulate him and wish him all the best.”
ULFA’s anti-talk faction on Sunday blamed it all on the government’s divisive policies for the violence in Kokrajhar that claimed the lives of 15 people. In a statement sent to media, the outfit said that the governments have always attempted to divide the people of the state on communal lines and the recent disturbing incidents in Kokrajhar reflect this trend. According to ULFA, it is sad that in the land where people of different communities and religion have been living in peace and harmony such incidents of violence and hatred was taking place.