Skip to content Skip to navigation

Interacting with Indian media

The experiences of many Pakistani experts, intellectuals, journalists and showbiz in the past reflected that interacting with the Indian media is always risky. One’s point of view is twisted and spinned out of the context it was actually narrated in. Such kind of incidents had created untoward situations for Pakistanis interacting with the India media to send the message of love, peace and good neighbourhood for the sake of better understanding between the people of both countries. Many of such efforts and initiatives had been counter-productive rather enhanced the trust deficit between the people and institutions of both states.

I was a bit reluctant to accept the Guwhati Press Club offer to be a guest speaker on their “Meet the Press” programme on Friday November 9 on a video conferencing call. Having been briefed that the Guwhati Press Club members initiated inviting the guest speakers from the neighbouring countries to directly know the perspectives and challenges facing the bilateral and regional harmony and peace, somehow I nodded positive believing that all would be well. And, it went very well. Thanks to the scribes of the Guwhati Press Club for not locking horns on the difference of opinion on the conflicting issues. Especially I am grateful to Babul Gogoi and Nava Thakuria for remaining quite professional to keep the essence of objectivity in the course of interaction and afterwards while they released the brief of the talk to media. 

Pakistan-India politics, terrorism, transboundary issues, CPEC, USA, role of SAARC, people-to-people contact, good neighbourhood, art & culture, entertainment, hypered stories of conflicts and controversies and much more were discussed with the journalists who live four-hour journey by plane to the federal capital of India

Following are some of the excerpts of my talk the Gauwhati Press Club released to their media and a bit explanation not quoted in their media brief. “Come election season in India or Pakistan and politicians make hay with hate speech. Bashing the neighbour has always been the easier way out to seek some electoral lift, but political leaders need to be more responsible, considering the historically fraught relations between the two neighbouring countries.” 

In fact, the hate speech has given rise to the religious extremists in the politics on both sides. It had served the vested interest of only a few political elements. The ongoing election campaign in India is an example where the allegations of cross-border terrorism on Pakistan are the main content of their election slogans. ‘Modi ka jo yaar hae, gaddaar hae, gaddaar hae’ was one of the extremely hyped slogans of Pakistan Tahreek-e-Insaaf (PTI) in the May 2018 elections in Pakistan. This slogan was instrumental in lifting the PTI vote bank though by a little. But it damaged the overall image of Mian Nawaz Sharif who hosted Prime Minister Modi in Lahore and Murree with all ‘undue privileges’. Such kind of slogans and hate-speech against each other could serve temporary political vested interest on both sides of borders but in the long run it confuses more the already confused people of both countries. 

“Mr Ahmed maintained hard words against rabble-rousing elements in both Pakistani and Indian media as well. Bemoaning the rigid exclusion of each other’s media by governments of the two South Asian nations, he advocated for media exchange programmes as part of a broader people-to-people contact. Pointing out that elements of Indian entertainment and culture, including standard Bollywood fare, are quite popular in Pakistan, Ahmed posed a question, why we cannot allow each other’s official newscasters Doordarshan and PTV to be aired in the respective territories, nonetheless subject to necessary restrictions? “The initiative would help bring about better understanding of mutual concerns and perspectives at the grassroots,” said the outspoken journalist, who uses to be a regular contributor to Daily Times and participant to various programs telecast by PTV and other national news channels.” 

“Dwelling on the state of Pakistani media, Ahmed claimed that around ten English language dailies and several Urdu dailies and periodicals are thriving and they enjoy significant degree of independence. However, alternative media is also booming with nearly half the 210 million Pakistani population hooked to various social media platforms, stated Ahmed admitting that some social media users do get carried away, often making extreme and anti-national comments. He admitted that there is need to regulate the social media.” 

“Stressing the importance of resolving the long-standing Kashmir dispute for overall improvement in bilateral relations, Ahmed however pinned the blame for terror activities on fringe elements. Think of the improvements the two countries can make in the lives of common people, if only huge expenditure is not necessitated in mutual conflicts, he asserted.” 

“We should all ask ourselves as to which third party has been benefiting with the two neighbours remaining always on loggerheads?” questioned Ahmed adding that a beginning can be made by regional associations like SAARC playing a pro-active role to bind member-countries together at one level, as well as international groups like Lions Club and Rotary Club working to improve popular contact at the ground.” 

Most importantly I urged the journalists to write on the US influence as how it has been creating and enhancing the conflicts in the region. Now our governments, politicians and media need to understand and emphasise on curtailing the US influence and interventions in the region for more economic and political stability for the sake of peoples’ prosperity. It’s time for the region to emerge as a bloc based on the indigenous strengths to combat the challenges confronting the region and the individual counties. Say a collective no to armed or unarmed fifth generation strategic or tactical interventions against any of the country in the region. 

Responding to the CPEC, I believed that the infrastructure developed in Pakistan would benefit the entire region. Even India and other neighbouring countries could benefit from the CPEC interventions if they maintain positive, friendly and peaceful relations with China and Pakistan and don’t hatch any conspiracy against the two countries in connivance with the external elements. 

I believe, proving to be a good neighbour, India also needs to rethink its policies on the transboundary environmental and climate issues too including the air pollution and water crisis. Both have caused enormous loss to Pakistan. 


The writer is an Islamabad-based policy advocacy, strategic communication and outreach expert. He can be reached at He tweets @EmmayeSyed 

Published in Daily Times, November 13th 2018.

Author info

Munir Ahmed's picture

Add new comment


Republish this content

Pak flag in Udalguri: Gogoi wants to go for CBI probe

12 Oct 2008 - 4:06pm | editor

The Assam government will go for a CBI probe into hoisting of a 'Pakistan flag' in clash-hit Udalguri district.

Talking to reporters on Saturday in Dispur, Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi said, “I would go for a CBI inquiry as they have the resources to find out the real culprits, whom we can punish and also educate the people not to be influenced by them.”

He said CID will also investigate so as to immediately know who were responsible for the violence as the CBI would take sometime for the probe.

According to the Chief Minister, "a judicial probe, already on, will unearth the conspiracy behind the clashes and hoisting of the flag.”

Meanwhile, the Assam government spokesman Dr Himanta Biswa Sarma has denied any reports of raising of the flag of the neighbouring country in Udalguri.

Have faith on Gogoi: Himanta

17 Jun 2014 - 11:49am | AT News
Health minister Dr Himanta Biswa Sarma has reposed his confidence on Tarun Gogoi as Chief Minister.
Addressing a press conference in Guwahati on Monday,  Dr Sarma who led the dissident group said that he had no difference with Gogoi and that he was prepared to do whatever the chief minister wants to do.

Revenue officer suspended for graft

3 Jul 2018 - 9:30pm | Shajid Khan

TANGLA: The Land and Revenue Department of BTC had suspended a revenue officer of Harisinga Revenue Circle Office on charges of graft on Monday. The long time allegations of a section of public that the officials have to be bribed to move any file where proven true after a video of a revenue officer(Lot Mandal) of the Circle Office caught accepting bribe on camera went viral in social media sites. Reportedly, the revenue officer, identified as one Numal Daimari had allegedly accepted bribe of Rs. 10,000 from a person for registration of land. The Udalguri district administration had also informed the media persons of strict disciplinary action against the official.