Skip to content Skip to navigation

Degenerated press club invites unwanted controversy

By Nava Thakuria |

A recent controversy erupted following a social media post by a television journalist, associated with Gauhati Press Club (earlier Guwahati Press Club) in northeast India, brought many questions for the media body, which invited a minister in Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma’s cabinet for a cultural program, but shockingly ‘faced derogatory comments’. The particular post was generated by the journalist working for a satellite news channel owned by the CM’s family, and his outburst that the State health & family welfare minister Ashok Singhal disrespected a delegation from GPC, was taken seriously. According to the journalist, the GPC delegation went to invite Singhal for a forthcoming Bhaona performance in the city. During the brief interaction, the minister allegedly questioned the necessity of a press club to organise a Bhaona. Moreover, the minister termed the native traditional performing art-form as not being secular in nature.

The issue suddenly had gone viral as many individuals, outfits, media outlets and opposition political leaders started making a hue & cry demanding an apology from the minister. Some even termed Singhal as a ‘non-Assamese’ who has no idea about the religious performing art form (Ankiya Bhaona), developed by the sixteenth century Vaishnavite saint, scholar and philosopher Mahapurush Srimanta Sankardev and his prime disciple Madhavdev to enact plays primarily with mythological characters. However, CM Sarma opined that he did not believe Singhal could make such an immature comment. It was followed by a formal clarification from Singhal denying the allegation that he made such derogatory remarks regarding the Bhaona.

Later in a social media post, Singhal stated that it was completely ‘false and fabricated’ after acknowledging that a group of scribes visited him to invite for the cultural program, but a fictitious story was generated by a particular journalist. Singhal tendered an apology citing the reason that he did not  want any unnecessary debate over the matter, but he stuck to his stand that he never made any derogatory remark on Bhaona. The issue should have been resolved after the minister’s apology and the GPC was seemingly happy with the development (though it was half-hearted), but soon the city press club made a puzzling statement that the meeting with  the minister was not prescheduled. A statement in Assamese language, endorsed by GPC president Susmita Goswami and general secretary Sanjay Rai, claimed that they came to know about the meeting with Singhal from social media only.  

The social media users questioned why the particular minister was invited even though he is not in charge of IPR or cultural ministry? Moreover, why did the GPC delegation approach the concerned minister at his residence in the evening hours (but not in the Secretariat)? More precisely, why would a minister make derogatory comments just to receive an invitation for any event? Was there any instigation and it was none other than a demand for some hefty donations from the minister, but somehow it was  materialised? Why the GPC committee will not apologise to the media fraternity for the mess as  the Bhaona titled ‘Gandharir Abhishap’ was already supported by the North East Zone Cultural Centre  under the Union Ministry of Culture, New Delhi?

The media club, currently functioning illegally from Ambari archaeological site,  claims that it has nearly one thousand members, but many city-based scribes publicly stated that they are not associated with the GPC. The club, which celebrated the golden jubilee year of its existence in 2022, but its closing function is yet to be organised. Many conscious citizens now  demand to relocate the press club so that the rich archaeological site  could be preserved for research works.  The archaeology department claims that the ruins of Ambari reflect the period of Sunga-Kushana dynasty. So the Ambari site, which attracts daily visitors from different parts of India, needs to be made encroachment-free, with no sympathy to the illegal occupiers including the press club.

  • 6372 reads

Add new comment

Other Contents by Author

Singer bats for State Sangeet Natak Academy

Acclaimed Assamese music composer and singer Kula Barua emphasizes on a State Sangeet Natak Academy for the benefit of performing artistes and also the new generation who would study the Assamese culture in future. Attending the ‘Guest of the Month’ program at Guwahati Press Club on Thursday (2 November 2017), the soft spoken gentleman also insisted on relentless appreciation of Assamese music and songs. Answering various questions raised by the participating journalists, Barua expressed concern that the lyrics have now been ignored by a section of present time singers. He remembered Dr Bhupen Hazarika’s contribution to modern Assamese lyrics and termed him as an emperor who used to create...

Physiotherapy camp organized at press club

On the occasion of World Physiotherapy Day, a physiotherapy camp has been organized tomorrow (8 September 2017) at Guwahati Press Club. The free camp, open for all member-journalists of the press club, will start at 1 pm and conclude by 5 pm. The camp, planned for detailed physical assessment & effective treatments for the participants, will be supervised by senior physiotherapists namely Dr Kangkan Talukdar (PT), Dr Lopa Das (PT), Dr Pankaj Das (PT) and Dr Pooja Saikia (PT). They will be assisted by a number RCPHS, CPMS, ADTU College students namely Anuradhapura Das, Rupam Kalita, Munindra Gogoi, Rijuwana Begum, Himashree Medhi, Soni Phom, Gautam Das, Sneha Das, Sasanka Mahanta, Mr...

CP Saikia memorial meeting at press club on Tuesday

Journalists and well-wishers have decided to pay homage to Chandra Prasad Saikia, a renowned author-journalist of the region, at a function organized in Guwahati Press Club on August 8 on the occasion of his 11th death anniversary. Padma Bhusan CP Saikia mentored many journalists of Assam during his tenure as the editor of Natun Dainik, which heralded a new wave of modern journalism. The illustrious editor-journalist was also credited for initiating the book fair movement in the State since 1984. As the secretary of State publication board, he not only edited Prakash, an Assamese literary magazine, but also took leadership to publish a number of invaluable books like Hasti Vidyarnava,...

Weekly clinic at press club roles on

Nilakantha, a middle-age scribe of Assam, participated in the weekly evening OPD clinic at Guwahati Press Club out of curiosity. He had a brief discussion with the attending doctor, who advised him to check his blood pressure. Initially Nilakantha asserted that he had no pressure (meaning no irregularity in BP). But when the sister in the camp measured his blood pressure, the outcome emerged simply shocking. He had hypertension (280 by 170), which compelled the doctor to strongly advise him to take medicine urgently. Meet Jyotiprasad, a young contributor of news & features to local newspapers in the city, who casually came to press club on a Saturday. He was asked to consult with the...

Community work to conserve bird

The news was astonishing as an Assamese lady was selected for Whitley Award, also known as Green Oscar, and invited to London to receive the coveted award. Suddenly Purnima Devi Barman emerged as an icon across Assam. But the residents of many parts in Kamrup were familiar with the and her mission to conserve Greater Adjutant Stork (popularly known as Hargila or Dhadang). Purnima, 37, has been working in the villages since 2009 where once the people found the bird as dirty, but today they feel proud of it and virtually own the responsibility to preserve the tall bird’s habitats adjacent to their localities. The rural ladies came forward to join hands with Purnima to adopt the birds as...

Apollo gynecologist attends press club OPD

Senior gynecologist from Apollo Chennai Hospital Dr A. Vinutha on Saturday (6 May 2017) attended the evening OPD clinic at Guwahati Press Club and offered free healthcare consultations to around 20 participants. The program, organized under the ‘Evening with a Doctor’ series, was exclusive for women journalists and spouses (and daughters) of the press club members. Prior to it, the experienced gynecologist delivered a talk on various women related ailments and their preventions at the press club auditorium, where around 50 participants interacted with the physician. It was organized by Apollo Hospitals Information Center, Guwahati in association with the press club. The next media OPD...

Former students’ get-together at Makhibaha HS School

The entire batch of 1982-83 high school leaving certificate examination participants from Makhibaha High School (now an HS standard) under Nalbari district of central Assam will assemble along with their families on 16 April next in the school campus. The get-together programs comprise felicitation/ tributes to former teaches, commemoration of batch mates, plantation, cultural shows and vivid interactions. A small convener committee under the leadership of Hareswar Dutta (96134 51514), Narayan Majumder, Nabadeep Bharali, Utpal Bhattacharya, Golak Pathak etc was also formed to plan the ceremony, which is expected to be an annual affair.

Sri Lankan filmmaker to attend GPC program

Eminent Sri Lankan filmmaker Prasanna Vithanage will attend the ‘Guest of the Month’ program of Guwahati Press Club on Tuesday (11 April 2017). The interactive session will start at 11 am and continue till 12.30 pm. Born at Panadura, an outskirt locality of Colombo in 1962, Vithanage emerged as an acclaimed visual translator of inner conflicts carried by ordinary people along with their journey for individual freedom. He has received international acclaim for ‘Sisila Gini Gani’ (Ice of Fire), ‘Anantha Rathriya’ (The Dark Night of Soul), ‘Akasa Kusum’ (Flowers of the Sky), ‘Pura Handa Kaluwara’ (The Death on a Full Moon Day), ‘Ira Madiyama’ (August Sun), ‘Oba Nathuwa Oba Ekka’ (With You,...

Ayursundra doctors conduct OPD clinic at press club

Ayursundra Superspecialty Hospital conducted the weekly evening OPD clinic at Guwahati Press Club on Saturday (1 April 2017) for the benefit of its members and their dependants. Dr Prerit Sarma (Emergency Medicine) and Dr Ayona Barthakur (O&G) checked the health status of over 35 participants and offered necessary consultations. Besides health related free consultations, the participants also got the facility of weight, blood sugar, pressure examinations in the brief camp. The camp was assisted by Satyabrat Baruah (public relation officer), Bijoy Sankar Nath (marketing), Manab Kr Kalita & Jayanta Kalita (pharmacist) and Bandita Kalita (nurse) from the newly launched healthcare...

JFA lauds HC ruling

Journalists’ Forum Assam (JFA) expresses happiness and gratefulness over the recent Gauhati High Court directive to the management of Janasadharan, an Assamese daily newspaper to clear all the unpaid wages of the employees till January and also make an endeavour to pay the current wages accordingly. The court also asked the management of Janasadharan Printing and Publication Ltd to restart publishing the newspaper, which has already been honoured by the proprietor with full cooperation of the employees. Janasadharan, owned by Congress leader Rockybul Hussain and then edited by Left intellectual Dr Shivnath Barman, was suddenly stopped from publication by the management in last November,...