Skip to content Skip to navigation

Legal Notices Served to Halt HPV Vaccine Rollout in India

In a significant development, legal notices have been served recently to the Chief Secretaries of 15 Indian states and union territories, demanding the immediate cessation of the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination campaign. Advocate Mitali Sett issued the notices on behalf of senior gynecologists and members of the Awaken India Movement, citing concerns about informed consent, potential health risks, and non-compliance with Supreme Court mandates.

Key Details of the Legal Notices

The notices allege violations of the Supreme Court's directives in the landmark case Jacob Puliyel vs. Union of India, which emphasizes the "golden rule" of informed consent. The directives mandate:

  1. Parents cannot be questioned for refusing consent for vaccines.
  2. Authorities and healthcare professionals must ensure parents are fully informed about vaccine contents and potential adverse effects.

The legal documents also demand wide dissemination of information in local languages about vaccine risks to ensure transparency and public understanding.

States and UTs Covered

The legal notices were served to the following states and UTs via speed post and email:
Delhi, Bihar, Chandigarh, Punjab, Haryana, Maharashtra, Goa, Kerala, West Bengal, Assam, Meghalaya, Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, and Chhattisgarh. Notices for other states are expected to follow soon.

Allegations and Concerns

The notices raise serious concerns about:

  • The lack of sufficient scientific evidence proving the efficacy of HPV vaccines in preventing cervical cancer.
  • Reports of adverse effects such as autoimmune disorders, Guillain-Barré Syndrome, fertility issues, and other health complications.
  • Non-disclosure of vaccine ingredients, adverse effects, and limitations in official advertisements and patient information booklets.

Additionally, the notices highlight international controversies surrounding HPV vaccines, including reported deaths during trials in India and abroad, and call for a halt to mass vaccination drives pending further studies.

Demands Made in the Notices

The notices list several pre-requisites for resuming HPV vaccinations, including:

  • Wide publicity of potential side effects and risks in local languages.
  • Transparent disclosure of vaccine ingredients and patient information booklets.
  • Comprehensive health evaluations of recipients before vaccination.
  • Risk-benefit analysis for each recipient.

Advocate Sett and the complainants argue that these measures are essential to safeguard the health and rights of young girls targeted by the vaccination drive.

International Context and Financial Concerns

The notices also reference studies and expert opinions questioning the causative role of HPV in cervical cancer. They criticize the financial implications of mass vaccinations, suggesting that funds could be better utilized for early detection and treatment programs, such as Pap screenings.

Broader Implications

The legal notices not only call for the cessation of the HPV vaccination program but also highlight broader concerns about public health policies, vaccine safety, and ethical medical practices in India. The Awaken India Movement has urged parents, schools, and state agencies to refrain from participating in the campaign until these issues are resolved.

For further details, the state-wise legal notices and covering letters can be downloaded online. Recipients are warned of legal consequences if the demands are not met promptly.

This development underscores the need for a transparent and evidence-based approach to public health initiatives, balancing the benefits of vaccination with the rights and safety of individuals.

 

Reference: https://awakenindiamovement.com/legal-notices-served-to-chief-secretarie...

Add new comment

Other Contents by Author

Guwahati: Consumer Legal Protection Forum and Consumer VOICE, New Delhi is consumer protection organizations working to promote road safety. They organized a stakeholder workshop at hotel Aarian Atithya, Guwahati today. The main objective of the workshop was to strengthen the road safety aspects of MVA 2019.   Recently the Motor Vehicles Amendment Act 2019 has been passed and got assent of the President of India. This amendment aims to make Indian roads safer, reduce corruption and use technology to overhaul the country's transportation system. The next step is to frame the Motor Vehicle Rules by Central and State governments to implement the amended law for improving road safety...
Tribal Vaganza , a festival of music, films, culture and indigenous games will be held on 13th & 14th September 2019 at Bethel School Compound, Old Showuba, Dimapur suburbs in Nagaland. The festival will commence with Indigenous games like , open oiled bamboo  pole climbing competition and bamboo stilt race at 2.50 pm in the afternoon and in the evening from 6pm, there will be a pre release  Film Premiere of “EnterMy World”   Shri. Temjen Imna Along, Hon’ble Minister of  H  & TE and Tribal Affairs will graced the occasion as special invitee. There will be a mega concert on day two at 6 pm featuring , Fiddlecraft  from Pune, Reuben Mashangwa’s...
Guwahati: Dr Rela Institute & MedicalCentre, Chennai has organized a daylong Hepatitis B and C screening camp atGuwahati Press Club on 9 September 2019 (11 am to 3 pm). Subsequentexpert opinions by consultant hepatologists from the multi-speciality hospital (with necessary privacy) will also be made available for those participants on 14 September (11 am to 3 pm), who test positive for the disease. Currently, chronic Hepatitis B and C are themajor burden of the liver diseases in India which eventually lead tocirrhosis of the liver and hepatocellular carcinoma. However, a simple screening test can provide anopportunity to treat the disease and to identify patients, who are atrisk of...
THIS is for your kind information and necessary action 1. Yesterday, the office of the State Coordinator, NRC Assam released a press statement on the publication of the final NRC as on 31st August 2019.   2.  Since then, there have been commentaries in sections of the foreign media about aspects of the final NRC which are incorrect.   3.  Let me begin with the background.  Government of India signed the Assam Accord in 1985 with the promise to take care of the interests of the citizens of Assam.  NRC aims to give effect to the Assam Accord signed in 1985 between the Government of India, State Government of Assam, the All Assam Students Union (AASU) and...
The process of NRC Update was started in the state of Assam as per order of the Supreme Court of India in 2013. Since then, the Apex Court has been closely monitoring the entire process. The process of NRC update in Assam differs from the rest of the country and is governed by Rule 4A and the corresponding Schedule of the Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National Identity Cards) Rules, 2003. These rules have been framed as per the cut-off date of 24 th March (Midnight), 1971 decided as per Assam Accord. The process of receipt of NRC Application Forms started during the end of May 2015 and ended on 31 st August 2015. A total of 3,30,27,661 members applied through 68,37,...
While mainland India prepares for its 5 trillion dollar economy, in the remote areas of Mahendraganj, in the Northeastern state of Meghalaya, we find village Communities which are almost untouched by urban life. In Mahendraganj a larger number of people are suffering from skin diseases that affect entire households. On 16th August 2019, I came to know about this problem because few of the girls working in our Apparel making Production Centre at Mahendraganj were suffering from skin infection. When asked about it, they reported that the problem is very huge and almost everyone in the villages is suffering from this problem. Then I visited three villages and found that large number of...
This is an invitation for papers. Concept Note of the Seminar Role of Religion in Peace and Conflict Processes in Northeast India Organiser: North Eastern Social Research centre, Guwahati 15th – 16th November 2019 Venue: Seminar Hall, Jagriti 3rd floor Religion occupies an important place in the life of human communities as a powerful constituent of cultural norms and values. Because it addresses profound existential issues of human life, it is deeply implicated in individual and social conceptions of peace. However, during the last few decades in India as a whole the main religions, Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism and Islam have been playing an even more important role than in...
Guwahati: Leading orthopedic & sports medicine specialist Dr KL Praveen Kumar from Apollo Hospitals, Chennai today (24 August 2019) conducted the weekly media OPD clinic at Guwahati Press Club. Member-journalists along with their families suffering from sports injuries or any other orthopedic problems availed the opportunity to consult with Dr Kumar at the press club premises. Rupjyoti Barua, marketing manager of the hospital was also present on the occasion.
‘Dignified way for return of Kashmiri Pandits obligatory’ Guwahati: The return of Kashmiri Pandits to Kashmir valley must be addressed in terms of historical aspect than a cosmetic contemporary understanding. This community has suffered a genocide for last 700 years and has been eventually reduced from cent percent presence in the valley to hardly three percent now, commented a senior journalist of Jammu & Kashmir. Tito Ganju, editor-in-chief of Epilogue, an English newsmagazine published from Jammu, while interacting with Guwahati Press Club member-scribes through the video-conference facility on 23 August 2019, also added that safety, dignity and opportunity should for the cardinal...
Lorence Kachari Film's  new music video titled 'sokute soku thole'  is out ..Sung by nakshatra ,cast -Vivek & Ygusmita Kachari, who hogged the limelight in 2015 when he directed a music video for Diphu-based rock band Celestial Sphere. The music video, titled How I Wish, was aired on VH1. Fans are already appreciating the entire vibe, and of course turning it into memes. One fan wrote, "THANK YOU FOR THIS MASTERPIECE," while another added, "I TOOK A BREAK AT WORK AND IM WATCHING IT IN THE BATHROOM I LOVE IT LOL." Same.